Failures and service

Hydraulic Pump Failure: Warning Signs, Causes and Prevention

A hydraulic pump rarely fails without warning, and rarely fails on its own. We show 4 warning signs worth acting on, 6 causes that destroy pumps, and what to do so the new pump doesn't end up the same way.

SH 12 min read
Hydraulic pump failure – 4 warning signs and 6 causes
Table of contents (16)
  1. Signs of hydraulic pump failure
  2. Before you replace the pump: 4 things to check
  3. Causes of hydraulic pump failure
  4. What to do if you notice any of these signs
  5. How to prevent pump failures
  6. Replacement, repair or OEM: what makes sense

An excavator that lifted its bucket without trouble six months ago now does it noticeably slower. The operator says it "feels a bit weaker", but the machine still works, so nobody worries. A month later the pump stops completely. On the way, metal particles from the disintegrating pump destroy the control valve. A PLN 1,800 pump replacement becomes a PLN 7,000 repair.

We see this every week. Hydraulic pump failure rarely comes out of nowhere and rarely has a single cause inside the pump itself. First we show four warning signs worth acting on. Then the causes that destroy pumps, and what to do so the new one doesn't share the fate of the old one.

Signs of hydraulic pump failure #

Hydraulic pump failure symptoms – slower cylinders, noise, overheating, leaks
The four most common signs of a worn hydraulic pump.

1. Cylinders move slower than they used to #

This is the most common sign and the easiest to miss. The excavator arm still lifts, but slower. The loader forks still go up, but barely manage a full load. The machine still works, so the operator carries on.

The pump's internal parts (gears, pistons or vanes, depending on the type) wear over time and clearances open up between them. Through these gaps, oil leaks inside the pump from the pressure side back to the suction side instead of going into the system. The pump turns at the same speed, but less oil reaches the system, so the cylinders slow down. A 10–15% drop in speed shows that wear is progressing. A drop of 30% or more means a heavily worn pump.

A simple testTime how long it takes to fully extend a cylinder at the same engine speed and compare it with the machine documentation or with how it was when the machine was in good shape. If it takes noticeably longer, the pump is losing flow.

2. The pump has become noisy #

A healthy pump runs evenly: you can hear it, but the sound is steady. A change in sound usually appears long before a failure, so it's worth knowing what it means:

  • A high-pitched whine or whistle, louder under load, is most often cavitation: the pump isn't getting enough oil at the inlet.Knocking and rattling, like banging pipes, is usually air in the oil. Regular, rhythmic knocking can also mean play on the shaft or a loose cover.A whine that rises with speed even without load often means worn pump bearings.

3. The oil is overheating #

Hydraulic oil temperature – around 80°C is normal, above 95°C is too hot
Around 80°C is normal. Above 95°C, look for the cause.

Hydraulic systems in working machines usually run with oil at around 80°C, which is normal. Above 90–95°C the oil thins out, seals harden and the pump wears faster. High temperature comes from internal leakage in a worn pump, a clogged cooler, too little oil, blocked filters or a wrongly set relief valve. Hot oil is a spiral: it gets thinner, more oil leaks inside the pump, more heat is generated, and so on until failure. The easiest way to check is a non-contact thermometer aimed at the tank.

4. Oil leaks on the pump #

Hydraulic pump oil leaks – shaft seal, cover, ports, body
The four places where a gear pump most often leaks.
  • Shaft seal. It ages, hardens and stops sealing, especially after a standstill in frost.Ports. Loose fittings, damaged O-rings, cracked hoses.Pump covers. The seal between the cover and the body, unevenly tightened bolts.Cracked body. The worst case, usually from a pressure spike or very thick oil in winter. There's no repair here, the pump has to be replaced.

A falling oil level means the pump may start drawing in air, which speeds up wear. On top of that, oil on the floor is a slip hazard.

Before you replace the pump: 4 things to check #

What to check before replacing a hydraulic pump – sound, pump drive, oil level, air
Four things to check before you start taking the system apart.
  1. Listen to the system and compare the sound with the description above.Check that the pump is actually being driven. Is the PTO or clutch engaged, is the shaft turning, is the key or spline sheared? Plenty of "pump failures" end at this point.Check the oil level. A low level is the easiest way to draw in air.Check for air in the oil. If the oil in the tank is foaming, bleed the system first and only then assess the pump.

Causes of hydraulic pump failure #

A pump rarely fails on its own. Most often it is the victim of another problem in the system, and a new pump fitted to an unchanged system will fail for the same reason. Here are the six most common causes.

1. Contamination in the oil #

Hydraulic oil contamination – where it comes from and a hydraulic filter
Dirt in the oil is one of the most common reasons for replacing a pump. A good filter costs less than a new pump.

Most hydraulic system failures start with something in the oil that shouldn't be there: metal particles, sand, water, bits of old seals. Most dirt gets in through the tank: when topping up oil, through a damaged filler cap or a blocked tank breather. Other sources are wearing cylinders and the pump itself, oil breaking down at high temperature, dust coming in through worn rod seals and wipers, and new parts fitted without cleaning.

Dirt particles get between surfaces that must fit tightly: the gear faces and pressure plates in gear pumps, the pistons and valve plate in piston pumps. They wear them down like sandpaper, the gaps grow, the pump loses pressure and heats up, and even more metal particles appear in the oil. That's why a good return filter and regular filter changes are so important.

2. Air in the system (aeration) #

Normal, foamy and milky hydraulic oil – how to spot air and water in the oil
Foaming oil is a sign that air is getting into the system.

Air gets into the oil from outside: with a low oil level, through a leaking suction line or fitting, and through worn seals. It's easy to spot because the oil returning to the tank is foamy. A pump running with air can't reach full pressure, the oil heats up faster, lubrication gets worse, and in the end the bearings can seize.

3. Cavitation #

Hydraulic pump cavitation – air drawn in through a leaking suction hose
Cavitation starts at the inlet: the pump doesn't get as much oil as it tries to draw in.

Cavitation is not the same as aeration. The bubbles don't come from outside; they form in the oil itself when there is too much vacuum at the pump inlet: a clogged suction strainer, a suction line that is too narrow or kinked, oil that is too cold and thick, or the pump running too fast. Oil always contains some dissolved air, which is released under vacuum. When the bubbles reach the pressure side they collapse violently and tear tiny particles out of the metal. The damage shows as dull, rough or slightly pitted surfaces on the inlet side, most visible in aluminium gear pumps.

ImportantCavitation isn't "slightly louder running", it's active damage to the pump. If the pump whines, stop the machine and check the suction side: oil level, suction strainer, hose condition and fitting tightness.

4. Excessive pressure #

Excessive pressure in a hydraulic pump – gauge in the red zone and pump damage
Running above the pressure in the data sheet shortens the life of any pump.

Every pump has a maximum working pressure set by the manufacturer. The most common reason it's exceeded is a relief valve that is set wrong or stuck, sometimes a pump chosen for too low a pressure. The effects:

  • worn pistons and cylinder block in piston pumps,bent or broken vanes in vane pumps,a worn housing on the inlet side and broken teeth in gear pumps,a twisted, cracked or sheared drive shaft,a cracked housing, stripped port threads, damaged bearings.

Excessive pressure also damages valves, seals and hoses. After every repair it's worth checking with a gauge at what pressure the relief valve opens.

5. Wrong or old oil #

Hydraulic oil viscosity – too thick causes cavitation, too thin causes leakage and overheating
Oil that is too thick and oil that is too thin damage the pump in two different ways.

Oil must have a viscosity matched to the pump and operating temperature. Oil that is too thick (or cold) is hard to draw in, so cavitation appears. Oil that is too thin (or overheated) doesn't seal the gaps in the pump well, internal leakage increases and the system heats up. On top of that, every oil wears out over time, so change it at the intervals given by the machine manufacturer and don't mix oils of different viscosity.

6. Overheating and installation mistakes #

Overheating (described above as a warning sign) also causes further damage: it destroys seals, speeds up oil breakdown and changes the clearances in the pump. Installation mistakes are another common reason a new pump fails quickly: the wrong direction of rotation, starting without filling the pump with oil (a dry start can destroy it within seconds) or the wrong coupling.

RememberIf the old pump failed because of dirty oil, a new one in the same dirty system will end the same way. Before fitting it, find the source of contamination, flush the system, replace the filters and fill with fresh oil. We do this in our own service workshop and remind every customer.

What to do if you notice any of these signs #

Above all, don't wait. A failing pump sends metal particles through the whole system and damages control valves, valves and cylinders. The pump alone costs relatively little. A pump plus a control valve plus two cylinders is a very different amount.

  1. Stop the machine.Check the oil: colour, metal particles, foam, burnt smell.Inspect the pump: any leaks, are the fittings tight.If you have a pressure gauge, measure the pressure and compare it with the machine documentation.Call us or send photos and a description of the symptoms. We'll tell you how it looks and what we suggest.

How to prevent pump failures #

Hydraulic pump maintenance – checklist: oil, hoses, leaks, filters
A few minutes of checks before work cost less than machine downtime.
  • check the oil level before work and top up if needed,inspect the hoses: cracks, abrasion, bulges,look for signs of leaks at seals, fittings and valves,replace suction and return filters before they clog,change the oil at the intervals given by the machine manufacturer,keep everything clean when fitting new parts: remove plugs at the last moment and blow out lines before connecting them.

Replacement, repair or OEM: what makes sense #

Pump repair (remanufacturing). Makes sense for piston pumps (Rexroth A10V, Parker PV, Linde HPR and similar), where a new pump costs tens of thousands of złoty. We repair them in our own service workshop and give a warranty on the work. For gear pumps repair usually doesn't pay off, because a new pump costs about the same.

New pump (replacement). The most common choice for gear pumps: the same parameters as the original at a lower price. We keep most popular models in stock and ship the same day.

New pump (OEM original). For machines under warranty or when you need exactly the same pump as the factory one. Don't know your pump's number? See how to order a pump without a part number.

Tip for the futureIf the pump starts showing symptoms, don't wait for it to stop. Order a new one in advance. When the old one fails, the swap takes a few hours instead of a week waiting for delivery. Have a piston pump and prefer repair? Send it to us.

Looking for a pump or parts? Browse pumps for agricultural machinery, construction machinery and trucks, piston pumps, pump parts, filters and oil coolers.

What are the signs of hydraulic pump failure?

Most often slower cylinders, noise (whining, knocking), overheating oil and leaks on the pump.

What is the most common cause of hydraulic pump failure?

Contaminated oil, followed by air and cavitation at the inlet. A pump that is faulty in itself is less common.

Why is my hydraulic pump whining?

A high-pitched whine under load is most often cavitation: a clogged suction strainer, a suction line that is too narrow or oil that is too thick. A whine that rises with speed even without load can mean worn bearings.

How do I tell cavitation from aeration?

Aeration causes knocking and foaming oil, and the air comes in from outside. Cavitation causes a high-pitched whine and happens when the pump doesn't get enough oil at the inlet.

What is a normal hydraulic oil temperature?

In working machines, usually around 80°C. Above 90–95°C the oil loses viscosity and you should look for the cause.

What should I do before fitting a new pump?

Find the cause of the old pump's failure, flush the system, change the filters and oil, and fill the pump with oil before the first start.

Pump showing symptoms, or failed and you don't know why? Send us photos, we'll assess it and find a solution.

Contact us
Loading...